The 2012 Edgar Awards were announced recently and Neil Gaiman is nominated for a short story in the anthology A Study in Sherlock. As a great enthusiast of what I call Sherlock Holmes legacy fiction, it immediately went on my public library hold list. Curiosity about the state of anthology publication led to re-reading of old favorites and thoughts about new forms of short story collections.
I have always loved reading short stories, especially in my youth. Fascinating, eerie, funny, – there was always a story to be discovered or relished in the re-read. Collections with contributions from multiple authors were my favorite grab for going on a long or short car trip. They could be read quickly and the swift punches of the plot evolution kept me going back for more. Masters of the twist ending, wry humor, and perspectives on the ironies of life, short story writers were…